Failed Messiah
reports on a video showing an orthodox rabbi asking mayoral candidate Bill Thompson on the issue of metzitzah b'peh. Failed Messiah learned to become a rabbi at one point of his life. There are basic rules he knows or should know.
Rule # 1. That which has a consistent record shall not be changed, unless there is reason to believe otherwise (chazoka).
Rule # 2. Majority rules.
The applicality of these rules make a huge difference as to how and when a person may violate the Sabbath or drink milk from a cow.
There is always a risk of a natural death, and we never know when that day will be. However, I cannot drive to the hospital on the Sabbath or wear a heart monitor because some people have sudden strokes. The reasons are for the two rules above. First, I as an individual never had a stroke, thank God. Second, most people do not have random strokes.
Another law in Judaism is that milk from a sick cow is not Kosher. A cow is considered to be sick if it will die within one year. However, there is fool-proof way to know if the cow will live for at least a year without killing the cow and checking its lungs. Since this cow has a record of being healthy, and most cows live more than one year, the milk is therefore kosher.
The same law applies to metzitzah b'peh. Since the individual mohel has a clean health record and most people do not have h
erpes, there is no halachic risk of death for the child. A mohel who knows that he does have herpes and performs metzitzah b'peh is a murderer and we should have laws penalizing murderers. But the current law penalizes Orthodox Jews.
I have previously stated that Hershel Schachter, a rabbi at Yeshiva University, is responsible for the child abuse that occured in Yeshiva University. The difference there is that a reason to believe otherwise (the child's testimony) is valid, and according to Torah law, Schachter should have at the very least taken precautionary measures.
There are a couple of other issues I disagree with Failed Messiah. First, Bill Thompson only promises to "sit down and have a conversation" with the rabbis. This is a far cry from another mayoral candidate Erick Salgado who according to his spokesman, Joseph Hayon, "will do everything he can to make sure that the circumcision regulation (Metzitzah B'peh) will be repealed"
Also, the city agency's "public hearings" are nothing but show. Many people showed up against the MTA price increases that mayoral candidate Joe Lhota is directly responsible for, and the price still went up. Zoning public hearings are also just for show. $omething happen$ behind the $cene$ that no one i$ aware of.
If I were to guess who pulled the strings behind the scenes during the "public hearing" of metzitzah b'peh, it would be the gay groups. They hate Orthodox Jews more than the "off the derech" crowd. This would explain why Thompson is non-committal to repealing the metzitzah b'peh. Should he take a strong position supporting metzitzah b'peh, like Erick Salgado, he would lose his non-Quinn LGBT support . I don't get it. Yidel Perlstein isn't voting for Thompson.
In reality, more people die from drunk driving than from metzitzah b'peh. Since the politicians are the ones doing most of the drinking, there will be no stricter laws against drunk driving.
The topping is that the rabbi talking to Thompson says that metzitzah b'peh is a red line issue. Sorry rabbi, but research doesn't show me anywhere a violation of Torah law to vote or not to vote for a candidate based on metzitzah b'peh. I did
find one on gay marriage.
Yidel Perlstein holds it only applies to men.
The rabbi is either completely oblivious in politics, lied to Thompson, or is a denier of God's Torah (think Leviticus). Either way, he should be removed as rabbi.